Wednesday, 8 February 2012

Motives Underlying Media Selection

Guest post by WVU Communication Studies M.A. student Zac Goldman.

Media scholars continue to be interested in the motivation behind the consumption and selection of media. Early researchers like Paul Lazarsfeld indicated that people sought out media to perform one of three functions: informing, transmitting, or correlating. Numerous authors since have suggested the importance of media to also be entertaining. The growing amount of research regarding entertainment as the motivating factor and use of media is generally examined from a macro-level perspective. A narrower focus of this perspective may potentially examine how entertainment, or any motivation factor, alters the effects of the media content.

One frequently used approach to examining uses and needs of media is the Uses and Gratifications Theory (U&G). From this perspective, a generally accepted notion was constructed in that gratifications come from social and psychological needs. Although the theory has been used extensively to examine the psychological needs it has produced little predictive utility. The low predictive utility of the theory can logically be traced through the theory’s construction as it encourages recursive thinking; which brings further questions to the practicality of the theory.

The predictability (or lack thereof) of U&G is troubling and encourages alternative considerations. Now more than ever people have become active media users, rather than passive media audiences; and theoretical perspectives should reflect this.

The limited but powerful effects model examines media effects by reevaluating many of the previous models while incorporating key constructs which include the gratifications of social and psychological needs. Media content produces a cognitive, affective, or behavioral script (CAB) which is then received by the user. The user then internalizes this script with the psychological and societal needs in which they are facing. Only after the users complete the internalization will they determine whether to act on the script and demonstrate an CAB effect. In other words, the media content gives the user a puppet, but it is still the user’s decision and behavior which pull the strings and demonstrate the “effect”.

This perspective does not inherently assume that media produces what many would classify as an “effect”. Certainly the typical behavioral-based effect is possible within this model but no assumption is made that a user will demonstrate such an effect. However, as some would argue that discrepancies in the definition of media effects exist, the conversation resorts back to a macro-level perspective. If the definition of media effects shifts from its primarily behavioral connotation, the argument could be made that by learning something (from the script) which was previously unknown, an effect not only exists but it is assumed. Admittedly, this notion of media effects seems to be unpopular throughout the field.

So what are the implications? Well the importance of the user is rapidly becoming more recognized and appreciated than ever before. Previous perspectives of the media model which postulate that stimulus leads directly to response are becoming a thing of the past. The understanding of the moderator is critical in determining the importance of media effects (if any) within our society. The usage and motivation behind media consumption is arguably the starting point in conducting such research. Uses and Gratifications play a prominent role in determining the psychological needs of the user; however these needs must continue to be developed with societal needs to aid in determining their predictive utility as a moderator between the content and effects.

While the content of the media arguably gives the user the “bullets,” it is up to the user whether or not to “pull the trigger” which inevitably results in the media effect.


Wednesday, 1 February 2012

How does the channel affect the symbols?

(The following is a short post by WVU Communication Studies MA student Betsy Ditrinco, in reflection of our earlier class on media violence research)

In Albert Bandura’s chapter on the Social Cognitive Theory, he describes how mass media and the human brain interact to develop an understanding of our culture. In defining three human functions (symbolizing capability, self-regulatory capability, and self-reflective capability), Bandura explains how humans process information derived from mass media. The symbolizing capability “provides humans with a powerful tool for comprehending their environment and creating and regulating environmental events that touch virtually every aspect” of our lives (p. 122). The self-regulatory capability is the function that controls our motivation, emotion, and behavior through evaluations of our own behavior. Finally, self-reflective capability is how we cognitively verify our accurate thoughts against our flawed thoughts.

When we consume different forms of media, we are constantly assigning meaning to symbols and developing an understanding of our culture. The question is if media channels affect the symbols that are sent. In the aftermath of 9/11, how did we interpret the symbols that a local TV >news reporter sent differently from the messages sent by radio personalities? I would argue that radio may offer more room for visual imagination and potentially a longer connection to the image. Instead of watching the anchor tell you a story from behind a desk, you are only listening to the radio host, potentially visualizing ground-zero the entire time. There are clearly countless variances that can affect the messages sent across different forms of media; what are some that come to mind for you? Can you argue the opposite side of the radio/television example? Along these lines, there are even differences within the same medium on different channels. There are some organizations that produce extreme liberal or conservative views. Depending on the channel (or blend of channels) an individual subscribes to, this can impact the way the person views the world and verifies his or her own way of thinking. In the early 1900’s, mass media created a fear based on this idea- limited channels, limited thoughts. Now we face the reality of inconsistent symbols with varying interpretations. I would argue this leads to broader thinking and stronger critique but could you argue any negative effects?

Social Cognitive Theory and Media Effects

(The following is a short post by WVU Communication Studies MA student Jennifer Seifert, in reflection of our earlier class on media violence research)

In an explanation of Social Cognitive Theory, Bandura states that “symbolic modeling is central to full understanding of the effects of mass communication.” He argues that there are four major subfunctions that govern observational learning- attentional processes, retention processes, production processes, and motivational processes. Offering a simple explanation of each, the attentional process determines what is observed, the retention process determines what is remembered, the production process determines the plan of action, and the motivational process determines the cost/benefit of enacting a behavior.

It could be argued research centering on the effects of mass communication should measure outcomes or behaviors; however, this reflects a limited scope of the full effects of mass communication.  In the retention process, observers of mass communication transform the information they receive into "rules and conceptions of memory". Therefore, the effects of mass communication can precede the manifestation of behaviors.

Model of the Social Learning Process

Tuesday, 31 January 2012

Cultivation Theory

(The following is a short post by WVU Communication Studies MA student Melissa Ceo, in reflection of our earlier class on media violence research)

Gerbner and Gross developed Cultivation Theory to explain the effects that television viewing has on the general population. The basic form of the theory suggests that exposure the television’s singular messages helps develop viewer’s perceptions of reality. The main premise of the theory is that those viewers who spend more time watching television will be most likely to view the world through the “lens” of television’s repetitive messages.

The researchers also introduce the concepts of mainstreaming and resonance. Mainstreaming refers to the “blending” effect that happens when viewers adopt an outlook more consistent with the messages they receive when watching television, while resonance refers to the cases when what is viewed on television actually happens in real life. Most Cultivation Theory research examines the effects of media violence on the wider population. Although the Cultivation Theory has been widely studied, it has also fallen under criticism in recent years. The main criticism that has been identified is a lack in the presence of cognition. Cultivation Theory does not account for the role that human thought plays in the effectiveness of media messages. Another broad criticism of the theory is the possible lack of a single media message. What role does Cultivation Theory play in New New Media? Does it play a significant role?

Effects of viewing violent media

(The following is a short post by WVU Communication Studies MA student Gregory Cranmer, in reflection of our earlier class on media violence research)

The negative effects associated with viewing violent media has been thoroughly studied, with numerous publications concluding that viewing violence increases an individual’s risk of behaving aggressively(Potter, 2003). So the debate is settled, viewing media violence is bad… WRONG. Some scholars suggest that it is the act of viewing violent media is good in the sense that it exposes individuals to violence and allows them to decide that the violent act is wrong. Is it possible, can viewing violence actually be positive?

Yes, it is possible that some positive effects can come from viewing violence.For example,“NRA Gun Club,” a violent game about shooting guns de-glorifies gun use and promotes gun safety. Some would point to this as a positive outcome, and even go as far to suggest that without this exposure an individual’s decision about gun use is left up to random chance.

However, there are two problems with this logic. First, an individual’s decisions on anti-social behaviors will not be left up to chance without media. There are other factors, such as parenting and the already existing societal biases against certain behaviors that have influence over individuals. Second, for every exposure that may lead to a positive outcome, a negative outcome is guaranteed; desensitization to the anti-social behavior. For example, maybe exposing consumers to rape scenes will gross out the viewer and lead them to decide rape is bad. However, viewing the scenes will desensitize the consumer to rape. It’s a possible positive, but a guaranteed negative.

One has to feel that the desired message of “rape or violence is wrong” can be achieved without exposing the consumer to graphic displays.