The following is a post by WVU Communication Studies M.A. student Gregory A. Cranmer
Jeremy Lin, an NBA point guard and former undrafted free agent, has been thrust into the national spotlight after taking a sub-par New York Knicks team on a 7-0 run earlier this month. While the storylines of an undrafted free agent or former Ivy Leaguer selling out the “Garden” seems interesting, the majority of media coverage regarding Lin is racially focused. ESPN’s “A chink in the armor” headline regarding Lin’s first loss took the coverage of the first American-born NBA player of Chinese decent to another level. The headline featured a picture of a distraught Lin and was available on ESPN’s website for mobile devices for nearly 30 minutes before it was removed. The headline clearly had racial undertones, and the use of a racial slur in a headline for an athlete of another race does not seem as likely.
As a researcher with an interest in mediated sports coverage this story not only interested me greatly, but also parallels some of the main points of my thesis. First, the coverage of Lin demonstrates that the coverage of athletes is framed around their race. In my thesis, I focus on the use of brawn and brain frames to describe the successes of Black and White Heisman finalists and expect the established trend of Black athletes being framed as brawny and White athletes framed as brainy to continue.
Second, while there has been extensive research completed on racialized coverage of athletes in verbal commentary, written context has not been studied as often. The most likely explanation is that racialized coverage is easier to find in verbal commentary because it is live and requires commentators to continually fill air time under stress. However, that does not mean that written coverage isn’t racialized, as demonstrated by the Lin story. My thesis will also examine written content, specifically newspaper coverage. I decided to examine newspapers because written content is more powerful than verbal because in it is filtered through many channels (e.g., editors, unlike verbal commentary). This means for a piece of written content to reach the public it needs to be approved by many people who all support the content. The Lin coverage demonstrates that written context represents not just an author but a whole media outlet because ESPN and not the author of the story are being held responsible for the racist headline. Framing research supports the notion that racially based coverage is not individualized because frames are social shared and consistent over time. Mecurio and Filak (2010) suggested the mechanism behind such an idea is that younger reporters learn journalist practices from older reporters who are in positions of power. In essence, the younger generation learns to mimic the older generation in order to get more publishings, more interesting topics, and better locations in newspapers. Additionally, my thesis considers numerous other factors and antecedent conditions of frames including reporter race.
As technology allows for the media to communicate quicker, I believe the trend of seeing racially framed content will increase. Sports coverage provides a unique test of this belief because sites like ESPN are producing written content immediately after the conclusion of events, and even during the games themselves. The pressure to get this content out will likely hurry the process of coverage and reveal more racialized content similar to verbal commentary.
Sunday, 26 February 2012
Saturday, 25 February 2012
Developing an online version of Popnvics PICS for understanding digital relationships (COMM MIL research note)
In my recent research, I've been trying to get more into understanding the psychological dimensions of online relationships - particularly in terms of perceived closeness. I have a great respect for network analysis research that provides insight into the density of social networks, but I feel that this data at times is a bit 'cold' and assumes rather mechanistically and deterministically that we can understand the Gestalt of an interpersonal relationship merely by examining connections and communication frequency. While of course much social media research (including my own) is often more interested in connections over people, I'm trying to come up with novel ways in which to understand perceived closeness - that is, irrespective of one's location in my social media network (i.e. being proximal or more distal to myself as a node) or my communication frequency with another, what is my perception of your closeness to me?*
In looking for metrics, I came across the Perceived Interpersonal Closeness Scale developed by Popovics et al (2003) (.pdf here). They present an assessment of a graphical measure of perceived interpersonal closeness, conceptualized as (taken from the introduction of their publication):
So, how do we get this measure online? My first attempt (context, this is a study on brand propinquity hence the "brand name" in parentheses):
Before we move to the next section of the survey, we want to ask you one more question about your relationship with (brand name). Below you will see an image of a target that represents how close you are with different individuals in your daily life. Using this target, we’d like you to tell us how close you currently feel to them by marking the relevant answer from the bulls-eye below. To select an answer, choose the red number in the ring of the bulls-eye that best represents how close you feel to (brand name). You can make your selection by using the drop-down list provided.
Thoughts? I need to work on the presentation quality a bit - looking into coding a Flash-based version in which respondents could 'click and drag' from a list of friends, entities, or any other individual units of analysis and snap them to the bulls-eye graphic. I'm also considering a second layer of interaction where individuals might draw perceptions of the connected-ness between the entities on the map (but that's for another time); in effect, a perceived network density map that could be compared with the more objective measures of network density gleaned from social media data.
Reference:
Popovics, M., Milne, D., & Barrett, P. (2003). The scale of perceived interpersonal closeness (PICS). Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, 10, 286-301. [.pdf]
*Of course, I recognize that perceived closeness is likely strongly correlated with actual closeness from a network analysis standpoint, but I also wish to propose for the consideration that these two dimensions do not share a perfect correlation. In fact, the extent to which there is any lack of concordance between these measures becomes an interesting scientific question!
COMM MIL is the Media and Interaction Lab housed in West Virginia University's Department of Communication Studies. More information about the lab can be found here.
In looking for metrics, I came across the Perceived Interpersonal Closeness Scale developed by Popovics et al (2003) (.pdf here). They present an assessment of a graphical measure of perceived interpersonal closeness, conceptualized as (taken from the introduction of their publication):
During recent decades researchers and clinicians have shown an interest in studying and measuring closeness-related constructs, some of it in this journal (e.g. Timmerman, Emanuels-Zuurveen, & Emmelkamp, 2000). Sarason, Shearin, Pierce and Sarason (1987) defined the common factor underlying measures of perceived social support as ‘the extent to which an individual is accepted, loved and involved in relationships in which communication is open’ (p. 830). It is suggested that this core factor is interpersonal, socio-emotional closeness, a basic component and function of social support. Closeness, explicitly linked with a closeness–distance model of relationship is a richer and broader term than intimacy (Marks & Floyd, 1996).Their paper outlines a (rather elegant) argument in defense of their graphical measure of this construct, which essentially asks respondents to place relational partners onto a "bulls-eye" style map, with those individuals placed closer to the center as being more (perceptually) close to the respondent. Their data support and validate this measure, and while I haven't seen it's application much in other areas of research, I find it both inspiring and parsimonious.
So, how do we get this measure online? My first attempt (context, this is a study on brand propinquity hence the "brand name" in parentheses):
Before we move to the next section of the survey, we want to ask you one more question about your relationship with (brand name). Below you will see an image of a target that represents how close you are with different individuals in your daily life. Using this target, we’d like you to tell us how close you currently feel to them by marking the relevant answer from the bulls-eye below. To select an answer, choose the red number in the ring of the bulls-eye that best represents how close you feel to (brand name). You can make your selection by using the drop-down list provided.
Reference:
Popovics, M., Milne, D., & Barrett, P. (2003). The scale of perceived interpersonal closeness (PICS). Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, 10, 286-301. [.pdf]
*Of course, I recognize that perceived closeness is likely strongly correlated with actual closeness from a network analysis standpoint, but I also wish to propose for the consideration that these two dimensions do not share a perfect correlation. In fact, the extent to which there is any lack of concordance between these measures becomes an interesting scientific question!
COMM MIL is the Media and Interaction Lab housed in West Virginia University's Department of Communication Studies. More information about the lab can be found here.
Labels:
media psychology,
media research,
network analysis,
new media,
PICS,
psychometrics,
research notes,
social media,
social networks
Location:
Morgantown, WV, USA
Saturday, 18 February 2012
Wait.... We're all not hedonists?
%3Ci%3EThe+following+is+post+is+by+WVU+Communication+M.A.+student+Greg+Cranmer+on+Monday%27s+%2813+February%29+discussion+on+mood%2C+emotion%2C+and+entertainment+media.+%3C%2Fi%3E%3Cspan+class%3D%22fullpost%22%3E%0D%0A%0D%0A%22Stop+Watching+TV%2C+you%27re+melting+your+brain%21%22%26nbsp%3B+Despite+what+your+grandparents+say%2C+the+use+of+media+is+functional%2C+even+when+it+is+used+for+entertainment.%26nbsp%3B+The+traditional+conceptualization+of+entertainment+is+maximizing+pleasure+and+minimizing+pain%2C+which+is+also+known+as+hedonism.%26nbsp%3B%26nbsp%3BHedonism+has+been+culturally+ingrained+as+immoral+since+the+dark+ages%2C+thanks+to+religious+ideology+that+classified+leisure%2C+pleasure%2C+and+sin+as+synonymous.%26nbsp%3B+Classical+societies+%28e.g.%2C+the+Greeks%29+valued+not+just+leisure+but+entertainment.%26nbsp%3B+Aristotle+was+even+credited+with%26nbsp%3Bproclaiming+that+leisure+was+as+close+to+god%26nbsp%3Bas+one+could+get.%0D%0@%0D%0AIn+todays+digital+age%2C+the+use+of+media+is+not+only+popular%2C+it+is+the+main+means+of+entertainment.%26nbsp%3B+However%2C+the+difficulty+in+explaining+how+audience+members+gained%26nbsp%3Bpleasure+%28the%26nbsp%3Btraditional+definition+of+entertainment%29%26nbsp%3Bout+of+watching+tragedies+and+morally+objectionable+content+lingered.%26nbsp%3B+One+explanation+has+been+that+individuals+morally+disengage+from+content+in+order+to+gain+enjoyment.%26nbsp%3B+This+uni-dimensional+approach+%28i.e.%2C+media+consuming+always+being+pleasurable%29+depicts+the+audience+in+the+same+uni-dimensional+light%3B+they+are+essentially+reduced+to+hedonistic+creatures.%26nbsp%3B+%0D%0A%0D%0AOliver+and+Raney+%282011%29+provided+another+posible+explanation%2C+eudaimonia+%28i.e.%2C+meaningfulness%29.%26nbsp%3B+These+researchers+forwarded+that+individuals+are+entertained+not+only+by+pleasure%2C+but+also+by+meaningfulness.%26nbsp%3B+This+conclusion+answers+the+tragedy+conundrum+because%26nbsp%3Bindividuals+are+entertained+by%26nbsp%3Btruth+seeking.%26nbsp%3B+In+other+words%2C+while+individuals+do+not+enjoy+tragedy+they+appreciate+the+response+it+invokes.%26nbsp%3B+This+is+because+meaningfulness+is+about+the+self+%28e.g.%2C+self-reflection+and+self-cognition%29.%0D%0A%0D%0AHowever%2C+this+suggests+that+meaningfulness+cannot+be+accomplished+if+moral+disengagement+occurs.%26nbsp%3B+For+example%2C+it+can+be+argued+one+cannot+gain+meaningfulness+from+an+experience+if+they+remove+themselves+from+its+gravity.%26nbsp%3B+The+poet+Robert+Browning+asserted+that+it+is+through+meaningfulness+that+man+progresses%3A+%22Progress%2C+man%27s+distinctive+mark+alone%2C+not+God%27s%2C+and+not+the+beasts%27%3A+God+is%2C+they+are%2C+man+partly+is+and+wholly+hopes+to+be%22%26nbsp%3B+In+essence%2C+progress+and+meaningfulness+are+human+pursuits+alone.%0D%0A%0D%0AThe+idea+of+not+disengaging%26nbsp%3Bis+especially+relevant+for+use+of+violent+videogame+play+among+children.%26nbsp%3B+Grodal+%282002%29+suggested+that+videogames+are+an+%22emotional+labratory.%22%26nbsp%3B+His+point+was+that+while+videogames+provide+opportunities+for+a+controlled+situation%2C+they+produce+real+reactions+%28e.g.%2C+exictement%2C+fear%2C+sorrow%2C+anger%29.%26nbsp%3B+Videogames%2C+thus%2C+provide+great+platforms+to+attain+meaningful+entertainment.%0D%0A%0D%0AHowever%2C+despite+the+interest+in+these+two+motivations+for+entertainment%2C+a+relationship+between+them+has+not+been+established.%26nbsp%3B+One+unique+way+of+viewing+these+motivation+may+be+through+the+lens+of+the+Elaboration+Likelihood+Model+%28ELM%29.%26nbsp%3B+The+model+is+designed+to+explain+persuasion+and+how+it+is+achieved+in+two+ways%3A+central+and+peripheral+routes.%26nbsp%3B+The+central+route+involves+the+elaboration+of+messages+and+is+used+to+consider+ideas+and+consequences.%26nbsp%3B+The+peripheral+route%2C+however%2C+provides+a+quick+accept+or+reject+decision.%26nbsp%3B+This+results+in+the+central+route+having+the+ability+for+a+major+attitude+change+and+the+peripheral%2C+only+a+small+change.%26nbsp%3B+If+one+were+to+adapt+this+model+to+entertainment+it+is+likely+meaningfulness+could+be+equated+to+central+route+and+hedonism+could+be+equated+to+peripheral+route%2C+and+thus+meaningfulness+would+have+longer+lasting+effects+than+hedonism.%26nbsp%3B+%0D%0A%0D%0AWhat+does+the+dual%26nbsp%3B+pursuits+of+entertainment+say+about+human+nature%3F+Which+one+is+ultimately+more+important%3F%3C%2Fspan%3E
“I'm Attached, And I'm a Good Guy/Gal!”: How Character Attachment Influences Pro- and Anti-Social Motivations to Play Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Games
After a rather short wait, our research team of Nick Bowman (West Virginia University), and Daniel Schultheiss and Christina Schumann (Technological University of Ilmenau) are please to announce the publication of our article "I'm Attached, And I'm a Good Guy/Gal!”: How Character Attachment Influences Pro- and Anti-Social Motivations to Play Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Games" in CyberPsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking.
The study abstract:
One's feelings of intimacy and connectedness with distal, fictional media characters are referred to as parasocial interactions. Video games have challenged this concept, as the distance between game players and characters is greatly reduced, if not completely removed, in virtual environments. Games encourage the internalization and psychological merging of a player's and a character's mind, a multidimensional concept known as character attachment (CA). Data from our study suggest that dimensions of CA are useful in understanding both pro- and anti-social gaming motivations. Pro-social gamers feel a greater sense of control over their characters, while anti-social gamers are more likely to suspend their disbelief of the game environment and not take responsibility for their virtual actions. Pro-social gaming was more prevalent in older gamers, and younger male game characters were motivated by anti-social reasons.
We blogged about this study in an earlier post(here), and you can also view our presentation slides from NCA New Orleans below:
The study abstract:
One's feelings of intimacy and connectedness with distal, fictional media characters are referred to as parasocial interactions. Video games have challenged this concept, as the distance between game players and characters is greatly reduced, if not completely removed, in virtual environments. Games encourage the internalization and psychological merging of a player's and a character's mind, a multidimensional concept known as character attachment (CA). Data from our study suggest that dimensions of CA are useful in understanding both pro- and anti-social gaming motivations. Pro-social gamers feel a greater sense of control over their characters, while anti-social gamers are more likely to suspend their disbelief of the game environment and not take responsibility for their virtual actions. Pro-social gaming was more prevalent in older gamers, and younger male game characters were motivated by anti-social reasons.
We blogged about this study in an earlier post(here), and you can also view our presentation slides from NCA New Orleans below:
"I’m attached, and I’m a good guy!": How character attachment influences (pro-soci`l and anti-social) usage motivations
View more presentations from West Virginia University - Department of Communication Studies
Friday, 17 February 2012
Top papers in Communication and Technology - ECA 2012
A few weeks ago, we announced that our social media research team of WVU faculty Nick Bowman and David Westerman and Doctoral candidate CJ Claus had a paper recognized as a top paper in Communication and Technology for the 2012 Eastern Communication Association meeting in Cambridge, MA. The full slate of top papers for this division has been announced:
Friday (27 April) 9:00-10:15 AM Somerset Room - Royal Sonesta Boston
Top Papers in Communication and Technology
Chair: Heather Stassen-Ferrara, Western New England University
Respondent: Rod Carveth, Goodwin College
Our earlier blog post on the first draft of the paper can be accessed here. We'll look to get more information from the other authors and post accordingly!
Friday (27 April) 9:00-10:15 AM Somerset Room - Royal Sonesta Boston
Top Papers in Communication and Technology
- “Finding an Optimal Match: Social Support Groups in Second Life” Sara Green-Hamann and John C. Sherblom, University of Maine
- “How Demanding is Social Media: Understanding Social Media Diets as a Function of Perceived Costs and Benefits – a Rational Actor Perspective” Nicholas David Bowman, David Westerman, and CJ Claus, West Virginia University
- “Video Games: An Overview of Recent Research on Aggression and the Transition toward Considering Other Types of Effects” Ashleigh Shelton and Kenneth A. Lachlan, University of Massachusetts, Boston
- “Persuasive Technology: Transition to a Rhetorical Perspective” Raymond A. Lutzky, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
Respondent: Rod Carveth, Goodwin College
Our earlier blog post on the first draft of the paper can be accessed here. We'll look to get more information from the other authors and post accordingly!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)